Steel garage doors: gauge, core, finish and rust
The gauge, the core and the finish, and what Garaga's and Amarr's warranties say about dents and road salt.
Steel garage doors differ in four things you can check on a quote: the thickness of the steel skin, given as its gauge, the core behind it, the finish on its face, and what the warranty says about dents and rust. On the doors Garaga and Amarr publish, the skin runs from 23 to 27 gauge.
Protech Garage Doors sells, installs and repairs steel doors from Garaga, Amarr and Stanley. The range for garage doors in Ottawa is on display at the Nepean showroom, with garage doors in Mississauga and garage doors in London at the other two branches. The figures below come from each maker's own documents, read on 2026-11-19.
What the gauge of the steel tells you
Gauge is a number that runs backwards. Amarr's FAQ puts it plainly: the lower the gauge number, the thicker and stronger the steel. So 23 gauge is thicker than 26, and 26 is thicker than 27.
Here is what the two makers print for their steel models:
| Model | Build | Steel | Insulation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Garaga Regal | 2 in, one steel layer | 26 gauge | None, or polystyrene at R-7.2 |
| Garaga Vantage | 2 in, three layers | 26 gauge | Polystyrene, R-8.7 |
| Garaga Acadia 138 | 1 3/8 in | 26 gauge | Polyurethane, R-12 |
| Garaga Standard+ | 1 3/4 in | 26 gauge | Polyurethane, R-16 |
| Garaga Top Tech | 1 3/4 in, textured | 23 gauge | Polyurethane, R-16 |
| Amarr Lincoln LI1000 and LI2000 | 2 in, one steel layer | 25 gauge | None, or polystyrene at R-6.64 |
| Amarr Lincoln LI3138 and LI3000 | 1 3/8 or 2 in, steel inside and out | 27 gauge each face | Polystyrene, R-6.48 or R-9.05 |
Garaga's figures are from its comparative table for residential doors, and Amarr's from its Lincoln brochure. Every Garaga steel door in the table is galvanized and finished in baked-on polyester paint. Amarr coats its Lincoln steel in a 5-layer paint system.
Two things stand out. Inside Garaga's range only the Top Tech changes the gauge; every other steel model is 26. And Amarr's three-layer Lincoln carries 27 gauge on each face, against 25 on its single-layer door. Two doors with the same gauge can still be very different doors, which is why the next line on the quote matters more.
Why the core matters more than the skin
A steel door with a foam core injected between two skins behaves as one stiff panel. Garaga's guide to metal door construction says injected polyurethane sticks to the walls of the section and gives twice the resistance of a door the same thickness with a Styrofoam panel inside.
It goes further for a door with no core at all. By Garaga's figure, a 2-inch uninsulated door is less durable than a 1 3/4-inch polyurethane door by at least 122%. That strength matters most in a strong wind, or on a door left open all day.
Steel doors are sold both ways. Garaga's Regal and Amarr's LI1000 come with no insulation, and Protech's Ottawa branch says a single-layer steel door does the job in a detached garage nobody heats. For an attached garage, a three-layer polyurethane door adds the stiffness and dent resistance. What each R-value buys against an Ottawa winter is in insulated garage doors.
Dents, and what the warranties say about them
Garaga's own buyer's guide lists the trade-off for steel: the most popular material, long-lasting and low on maintenance, with a risk of denting, and of rust where the galvanizing is poor.
The warranty draws the same line. Garaga's maintenance and warranty guide, form 95850B dated January 2026, says that for all non-insulated doors, minor scratches and dents are not defects. It also excludes any cost from an accident, so a bumper or a snowblower is never a warranty claim.
Where one section is creased, Garaga's terms let it replace a single section rather than the door. Whether that or a new door makes sense is set out in repair or replace your garage door.
How road salt reaches the door, and how to stop the rust
The City of Ottawa spreads dry salt, wet salt and liquid brine on its streets, and sprays its rock salt with a liquid de-icer so it sticks to the road. The car carries it home, and the slush melts off at the foot of the door.
Amarr's care page says rock salt, ice melt and salt spray are harsh on steel doors. Its steps for a door exposed to salt:
- Wash the outside with warm water and a household detergent.
- Wash more often than once a year if you use salt to melt ice on the driveway.
- Never use a pressure washer.
The same page says surface rust from salt spray, salt or other ice melt is not covered by its product warranty. Garaga's lifetime cover on its insulated doors is for rust-through from cracking, checking or peeling paint in normal atmospheric conditions, which is a different thing from surface rust.
A spot that has started to rust
Garaga's painting instructions call for a zinc phosphate primer wherever the enamel is off and steel or rust shows, before the finish coats. Its warranty does not cover a door repainted by or for the owner, so on a door still under warranty, ask the dealer first. The rest of the year's washing is in the maintenance checklist.
Woodgrain finishes on a steel face
Both makers emboss most of their steel to look like wood. Garaga's table lists a light woodgrain finish on the Townships doors, Standard+, Acadia 138 and Vantage, and a textured one on the Top Tech. Amarr embosses its Lincoln steel with woodgrain too.
Garaga's colour lists include Weathered Grey Faux Wood and Dark Walnut, and Amarr sells its Classica carriage doors on the idea that from a distance you see wood.
It is a popular look on Protech's own work. Of the 43 residential doors in the job photos on Protech's Business Profiles, 13 finished doors show a woodgrain face. Eight of those are before-and-after shots, and every door taken out was a painted one in green, grey, beige, cream, white or brown.
The printed oak, walnut and cedar finishes on Garaga's flat modern designs are covered in modern garage doors.
Steel or aluminium
Garaga makes one aluminium door in its residential range, the H-Tech, at 0.60 mm with a rustic woodgrain finish and R-16 polyurethane. Its FAQ on aluminium says aluminium is lighter, easier on the opening mechanism and highly resistant to salt air.
It adds that on a door 12 feet wide or less, there is little difference between the two. Garaga's buyer's guide calls aluminium rustproof and also easily dented. So steel takes knocks better and aluminium shrugs off salt. Garaga counts the H-Tech's lifetime warranty as 30 years against 25 on its insulated steel doors.
How to compare two steel doors on a quote
Put the quotes side by side and ask for these in writing:
- The gauge of the skin, on each face if there are two.
- The core: none, polystyrene or injected polyurethane, with its R-value.
- The finish: woodgrain, smooth or textured, and the paint system on it.
- What the warranty says about rust-through, surface rust from salt, dents, and repainting.
- For a Stanley door, the model's specification sheet, held to the same four lines.
For the makers' history and their full warranty terms side by side, see garage door brands.
Seeing and measuring one with Protech
The photographs Protech publishes of its showroom show sample sections in several colours on rolling display stands, so finishes can be compared side by side. In Ottawa, the showroom at 46 Grenfell Crescent, Unit A, in Nepean is open Monday to Friday from 8 to 6 and Saturday from 9 to 2.
Then a certified technician measures the opening, the headroom and the side clearance at your home, and the door is made to measure. That visit is the start of garage door installation in Ottawa.
Call (613) 845-9950 in Ottawa, (289) 975-9045 for Mississauga and the GTA, or (226) 270-9715 for London. Every line answers 24 hours.
Questions people ask
Short answers to what comes up most often.
Who makes the best steel garage doors?
No maker publishes a ranking against another, so compare models. Garaga's Top Tech is the thickest steel in either maker's tables at 23 gauge, and its other steel doors are 26. Amarr's Lincoln runs 25 gauge on one layer and 27 on each face of three. Then compare the core and the warranty.
Are steel garage doors typically insulated?
Most are sold both ways. Garaga's Regal and Amarr's Lincoln LI1000 come with no insulation, and both makers sell polystyrene and injected polyurethane cores above them, from R-6.48 to R-16 on the models in the table.
What are the downsides of steel garage doors?
Dents and rust. Garaga lists a risk of denting, and of rust where galvanizing is poor, and its warranty does not count minor dents on non-insulated doors as defects. Amarr's warranty does not cover surface rust from salt or ice melt, so a steel door here needs washing through the winter.
Is steel or aluminium better for a garage door?
Garaga says aluminium is lighter and resists salt air, and that on doors 12 feet wide or less there is little difference between the two. Its buyer's guide also calls aluminium easily dented. Steel is the more common choice and takes knocks better.
What gauge of steel is best for a garage door?
A lower number is thicker steel, so 23 gauge is heavier than 26. Most residential doors from Garaga are 26 gauge and its Top Tech is 23. On an insulated door, the core does more for strength than a gauge or two: Garaga puts a polyurethane core at twice the resistance of a Styrofoam one.
Can wind bend a steel garage door?
A strong wind can, which is why Garaga ties a door's tensile strength to windy sites and to doors left open all day. Amarr offers wind load reinforcement on its Lincoln doors and says it is the owner's responsibility to make sure the door meets local building codes.
Where to go from here

Garage doors
Steel, aluminium and glass, wood and composite garage doors from Garaga, Amarr and Stanley. What the material, the layers and the insulation actually change.

Residential garage doors
Raised panel, carriage, flush contemporary and full-view residential garage doors. How the style, the windows and the hardware change the front of a house.

Garage door replacement
Panel damage, rust at the bottom section, repeated failures and an uninsulated door on a heated garage. The four cases where replacing beats another repair.

Garage door installation
Headroom, backroom and track type decide which doors will fit an opening. What an installation involves, and why the springs are sized to the new door.
Talk to Protech Garage Doors today
Call (613) 845-9950 at any hour, or email info@protechgarage.ca for a new-door quote with no rush.
